• Contact Us
  • Classifieds
  • About
  • Home

Pathway

Baptist & Christian News

  • Missouri
    • MBC
    • Churches
    • Institutions & Agencies
    • Policy
    • Disaster Relief
  • National
    • SBC Annual Meeting
    • NAMB
    • SBC
    • Churches
    • Policy
    • Society & Culture
  • Global
    • Missions
    • Multicultural
  • Columnists
    • John Yeats
    • Don Hinkle
    • Pat Lamb
    • Rhonda Rhea
    • Rob Phillips
  • Ethics
    • Life
    • Liberty
    • Family
  • Faith
    • Apologetics
    • Religions
    • Evangelism
    • Missions
    • Bible Study & Devotion

More results...

Photo made available by Kolombusjogger via CCL.

Monkey study challenged over Darwinian claims

May 9, 2016 By David Roach

NASHVILLE (BP) – A study of monkey calls hailed as evidence for the evolutionary origin of human speech has been critiqued by an Intelligent Design proponent as “flimsy” support for the Darwinian scheme.

An article in the Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society similarly has argued for the supernatural origin of language, stating that a divine creator is the “only reasonable way to account for” the phenomenon of language.

The study of African gelada monkeys – published April 18 in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences – may offer insight into common ways in which animals and humans vocalize sounds, but it does not explain how language came to convey “complex meaning,” said a biologist with the Discovery Institute, a Seattle-based think tank that plays a leading role in the Intelligent Design movement, which argues the universe is the product of intelligence rather than blind chance.

“Words can be combined to convey potentially any message,” Ann Gauger, the Discovery Institute’s director of science communication, told Baptist Press in written comments. “Language can be used to talk about itself; the sounds that convey particular meanings are arbitrary and dependent on conventions agreed to by the speakers; and language can convey events past, present, future or imaginary. These are just some of the characteristics of human language that resist any comparisons with animal vocalizations.”

The study, authored by two University of Michigan scholars and two Europeans, argues that gelada calls follow a linguistic principle known as Menzerath’s law, which states that longer sequences of language tend to have shorter components. In human speech, for example, longer sentences tend to contain shorter clauses, and longer words tend to contain shorter syllables. With geladas, longer calls tend to contain shorter “grunts,” “moans,” “wobbles” and “yawns,” as researchers classified the components.

The researchers do not believe different types of gelada calls communicate different meanings, but they argued the meaning of monkey calls is not important in establishing initial evidence for the evolution of language.

Gauger, of the Discovery Institute, called the study “a pretty flimsy piece of evidence for the evolution of language.”

“My dog barks faster when he’s in a fight with another dog over territory or dominance,” Gauger said. “Is he trying not to be interrupted or just to overpower the other dog? The last dog barking wins. It’s the same with monkeys, I would guess. But that has nothing to do with human language or its evolution. Language conveys complex meaning, and the meaning is not dependent on speed.” 

Comments

Trending

  • Third season of ‘The Chosen’ series: entertaining, but controversy grows
  • Four examples of where the New World Translation gets it wrong
  • Preaching ministry ‘an honor and privilege,’ Whitney says
  • What does the Bible say about marijuana?
  • What do Scientologists believe?

Ethics

First U.S. law banning public drag shows ruled unconstitutional

Diana Chandler

A federal district judge has ruled unconstitutional a Tennessee law prohibiting gender-bending drag performances in front of minors, which had been the only such law in the nation.

UK’s foremost expert: Gender ideology is ‘made up’

Will Hall

More Ethics Stories

Missouri

Preaching ministry ‘an honor and privilege,’ Whitney says

Aiden Trimble

Brother Frank Whitney stood up, took a deep breath, and walked toward the pulpit. Bible in hand, he double-checked his notes for the Sunday evening sermon. Tonight’s topic: faith the size of a mustard seed. The crowd wasn’t any larger than usual; about 30 people. It was just another Sunday evening service, except for one detail: The preacher, Brother Whitney, was 12 years old.

Copyright © 2023 · The Pathway