Fresh off the holiday hit The Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Lionsgate and Kingdom Story Company are in preparation for production on I Can Only Imagine 2, a sequel to the breakout hit "I Can Only Imagine." "I Can Only Imagine 2" will continue the inspirational true story of Bart Millard, once again played by Missouri native John Michael Finley – the son of Wayne Finley, a member of Heritage Baptist Church, Lebanon.